Do Your Ads Give a Reason to Choose You?

Free Why People Buy™ ROAS evaluation for food & beverage brands: shopper psychology + media audit in one. Pinpoint where you're losing buyers, fix acquisition gaps, and increase your ad return heading into 2027.

See the performance gap.

Ice cream ad creative
25%Above acquisition cost target.
$50 actual$40 target

Find your overlooked buyers.

Real everyday simplifiers.

Share of customers50%
Share of ad spend20%

Your biggest audience.
Your smallest spend share.

Test the segment you’re missing.

Reach everyday simplifiers with convenience-led creative.

Client engagements using the Why People Buy Pyramid™

MeatWorks8×revenue growth
Straus Organic118%more conversions

We will give you a clear snapshot of what to do next.

See how your ads perform, who’s buying, and where your targeting falls short.

Performance

Target$40

Actual

$50

+25% Above Target

Your results.
Your goals.

We compare performance against your KPIs and show the gaps.

Platform Review ↗

Customers

Beyond SelfPersonal GrowthEmotional ValueBasic Needs

Who’s buying.
What drives them.

We map your customers to the Why People Buy™ Pyramid.

Customer Segments ↗

Targeting

Customers50%
Ad Spend20%

↗ A gap worth exploring.

Your Buyers.
Your Budget.

We compare customer segments with ad spend to reveal targeting gaps.

Targeting Assessment ↗

One evaluation, two engines

Your ROAS is low because of why people buy.

1 · Shopper motivation

Why People Buy™

  • Category buyer tiers
  • Motives you're missing
  • Creative & packaging fit
+

2 · Media efficiency

ROAS engine

  • Wasted spend
  • Campaigns competing with each other
  • Signal & bid quality
=

Result

Higher ROAS

Predictable, scalable growth into 2027.

The findings. The gap. The next test.

Three steps to a clearer picture of what to test next.

  1. 01

    Share the basics

    Your brand, one ad platform, your KPI, and the customer info we need.

  2. 02

    We connect the dots

    We review performance, map customer motivations, and check your targeting.

  3. 03

    Get the one-pager

    Your main finding, the gap, and one recommended test. All on one page.

Find My Missed Buyers↗

Whether you work with us or not.

Four layers.
Deeper reasons
to choose you.

We use the Why People Buy Pyramid™ to segment your existing customers by what motivates them. Those segments give us a way to assess whether your advertising is targeting the right people, from practical needs to identity and shared values.

Higher layers build on the basics. They don't replace them.

Why People Buy Pyramid
  • Beyond SelfValues & community
  • Personal GrowthIdentity & aspiration
  • Emotional ValueComfort, reward & belonging
  • Basic NeedsTaste, nutrition, convenience & value

Better reasons.
Measurable growth.

MeatWorks

8×

Revenue growth

Two distinct buyer groups surfaced by customer research, each with its own messaging, creative and campaign structure.

Without increasing ad spend

MeatWorks ad creative

Straus Organic

118%

More monthly conversions in 6 months

Targeting and creative rebuilt around a specific buyer profile across Meta, Google and retail media.

Without increasing ad spend

Straus Organic ad creative

Client engagement results using the Why People Buy Pyramid™. Results are not attributed to individual ads shown here, and are not promised by the free evaluation.

Straus organic whole milk in a pasture
“Schaefer has been a game changer for our digital marketing strategy.”
Meryl MarrMeryl MarrVP Marketing, Straus Family Creamery

The questions we get
before the first call.

Is it really free?

Yes. One platform, one evaluation, no cost and no obligation. We do it because the findings are the clearest argument we have for how we work.

Do I have to give you ad account access?

No. You can share exports or read-only access, whichever your team prefers. We tell you exactly which fields we need.

How long does it take?

Five business days from the point we have your platform data and customer information. We confirm the KPI with you before we start.

What if we are not a fit?

You keep the one-pager and the recommended test either way. We only work with food & beverage brands, so we say so early if it is not a match.

Who we are

The Why People Buy™ agency for food & beverage brands.

We advertise everywhere people decide what to eat and drink: social, search, AI assistants, retail media, Amazon, Walmart and streaming TV.

We know food

Food and drink is all we do. 19+ brands.

We know shoppers

We research why people buy.

We know platforms

The technical side and the algorithms.

We make ads people notice

The right ad for the right buyer.

Easy to work with

Senior people, same-day answers.

2,121

food & beverage brands tracked

409,000+

ads analysed

129

Why People Buy drivers

Straus: −60% CPA, 5× ROAS and +118% monthly conversions in the first six months.

Intelligence → Strategy → Execution, starting with a 30-day sprint.

Real findings, names removed · both engines

What a Why People Buy™ ROAS Evaluation finds.

Not a checklist of settings. A clear read on where your money goes, why buyers choose you, and what to fix first.

Specialty pantry brand · ~$20M revenue · Google Ads

Return fell by half in seven months. The account was bidding against itself.

$41 → $96

cost per sale, spring to fall

2.9× → 1.2×

ad return over the same period

80%

of fall spend in campaigns returning 0.6×

1 · Why People Buy™ problem

Ads mixed different buying reasons (recipes, gifting, everyday staples) on one page, so shopper intent never matched the landing page.

2 · ROAS cost

Five campaigns bid against each other. $24K wasted and ROAS fell from 2.9× to 1.2×.

3 · Combined fix

Match each ad to one buying reason and merge into one clean Performance Max structure.

Same products, five campaigns

PMax A
PMax B
Shopping 1
Shopping 2
Shopping 3

Dark band: flagship products every campaign bid on. $24K spent on the overlap.

Ad return

2.9×
Spring
1.2×
Fall
3.2×
Target after fix

What we found

Bought up to five times

The same flagship products ran in 2 Performance Max and 3 Shopping campaigns at once. $24K went to the overlap at 0.4× return.

“Excellent” ads that weren't selling

Google rated every ad group Excellent, yet they ran 18-month-old creative, mixed products on one page and had no gift ads going into the holidays.

Sales counted that weren't sales

Free tasting sign-ups and test actions were counted as purchases, so Google optimised toward people who never bought.

Best campaigns paused before Q4

The two campaigns driving most revenue were switched off in late summer and budget moved to new tests.

The one-page fix plan

  1. 1One core Performance Max campaign built on what already works
  2. 2Purchases as the only goal Google optimises for
  3. 3Retire overlapping Shopping campaigns; tighten brand search
  4. 4Fresh, product-specific creative, gifting first

Brand names removed and figures rounded to protect client confidentiality.

Choose a platform.
Let's look at
the whole picture.

Tell us about your brand and the platform you'd like evaluated. We follow up to confirm your KPIs and the platform and customer information needed for your one-page evaluation.

  • One platform per evaluation
  • Five business days, start to finish
  • Yours to keep, whether or not we work together

Which platform should we evaluate?

What KPI matters most?Optional

5 business days · Shopper psychology + media audit · No cost, no obligation.

We reply within one business day. No sales call required to receive your evaluation.